On 12월 1, 2015, a new set of amended Federal Rules of Civil Procedure became effective after a lengthy rule-change process.  As part of the new regime of rules, a widely used form for filing patent infringement actions has been eliminated.  In the past, a form patent complaint would be used to allow patent holders to set the judicial process in motion without having to be overly particular in spelling out the alleged theories of infringement.  These forms are longer allowed.  New complaints must comply with the Supreme Court’s standard as laid out by the “Twiqbal” set of cases.  Patentees seeking for enforce their property rights in court will need to particularly allege enough facts to make a claim for relief plausible, or risk watch their suit be dismissed on a Rule 12(b)(6) motion.

In early November, the Federal Circuit issued a decision on an IPR proceeding which could affect future litigation.  In Belden v Berk-Tek, the defendant appealed the Patent Trial and Appeal Board’s (PTAB) ruling which upheld two of the six contested claims.  In the process, the Federal Circuit is supposed to give the PTAB’s factual findings substantial deference while reviewing findings of law de novo.  However, in its opinion, the Federal Circuit has suggested that a “motivation to combine” may be a question of law, rather than a question of fact as its currently treated.

With the change in the Federal Rules and the possible shift in Federal Circuit thinking, patent infringement litigation is like to change in the coming months.  However, will the new changes be a boon or a bane for patent holders?

Related Content

Webinar: Dissecting Alice at 5 – The Good, Bad & the Ugly Listen as Gene Quinn, President and CEO of IPWatchdog, Inc. hosts a special free webinar discussion focusing on the Alice decision five years later. J...
A Patent Examiner’s Take on ETA What might a USPTO examiner have to say about this new way to approach patent prosecution? The newest LexisNexis PatentAdvisor® metric has prov...
How to Improve Patent Prosecution Strategy The proliferation of data analytics tools has changed the way that patent practitioners approach their work. Many new features offered in these...

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. Cookie Policy

이 웹 사이트의 쿠키 설정은 "쿠키 허용"으로 설정되어 최상의 브라우징 환경을 제공합니다. 쿠키 설정을 변경하지 않고 이 웹 사이트를 계속 사용하거나 아래의 "동의"를 클릭하면 동의하는 것입니다.

닫기

汉语漢語DeutschFrançais日本語한국어English